Tuesday, 26 July 2016

Dubliners – James Joyce

How I remember my high-school classmates spending months and months reading (?!?) this collection of short stories and pretending that it was the most meaningful book they had ever read. Having read it over a lazy weekend I have a couple of thoughts (both for them and for whoever happens to read this blog):

1.       I understand it was cool to say that one was reading Joyce as a teenager, but, seriously, spending 2 months carrying it around feels a bit excessive – maybe my classmates needed to show off?
2.       I understand it was cool to say Dubliners was the greatest book they had read (perhaps it was factually true, as for a number of them it could have been their first book not written by Roald Dahl), but, honestly, what’s the point?

I have the feeling this is something that you can only appreciate if you’re Irish (probably like you can only appreciate Fenoglio’s short stories if you’re Italian), but if you aren’t – well, to restate my thought above, what’s the point?

1 comment:

  1. Sì, però a me la neve che cade alla fine di The Dead è rimasta in testa (tipo fermacarte pacchiano).

    Ma assolutamente non il miglior libro di sempre, anche solo perché bastano 5 pagine dell'Ulisse a sbaragliare tutti i Dubliners.

    ReplyDelete